ProtectedShare vs Firefox Send
Mozilla shut Firefox Send down in 2020. It encrypted files in your browser, put the key in the link, and deleted them after a set number of downloads or time. ProtectedShare's file drop works the same way, but only for files up to 25 MB, far below Send's 1 GB and 2.5 GB limits.
Feature comparison
| Feature | Firefox Send (closed 2020) | ProtectedShare |
|---|---|---|
| Available today | ||
| Available today | No | Yes |
| Encrypts files in your browser | ||
| Encrypts files in your browser | Yes | Yes |
| Key kept in the link after # | ||
| Key kept in the link after # | Yes | Yes |
| Files of 1 GB and more | ||
| Files of 1 GB and more | Yes | No |
| Download limit | ||
| Download limit | Yes | Yes |
| Expires after a set time | ||
| Expires after a set time | Yes | Yes |
| Optional password | ||
| Optional password | Yes | No |
| Works without an account | ||
| Works without an account | Yes | Yes |
| Open source | ||
| Open source | Yes | Yes |
| Self-hostable | ||
| Self-hostable | Partial | Yes |
What Send was
Mozilla introduced Firefox Send as a free service in March 2019. You could share files up to 1 GB without an account, or up to 2.5 GB after signing up for a free Firefox Account. Files were encrypted in the browser, the sender chose when the link expired and how many downloads it allowed, an optional password added a check before download, and recipients didn't need an account. Mozilla also announced an Android app in beta.
Mozilla's own FAQ warned that very large files could strain the browser, because encryption ran locally, and suggested staying under a few hundred megabytes for the most reliable results.
Why it closed
In the summer of 2020, Mozilla took Send offline after some users began using it to ship malware and run spear phishing attacks. In September 2020 it announced that Send would not come back. The source code is still on GitHub under the Mozilla Public License 2.0, archived since May 2021, and Mozilla asks anyone running a copy to remove its branding.
Where ProtectedShare's file drop fits
The file drop follows the same model. Your browser encrypts the files with AES-256-GCM, in 1 MiB chunks bound to their position, and the key stays in the link after #k=. File names and types are encrypted too. You choose 1 to 100 downloads and an expiry of up to 30 days, and the drop is deleted after the last download or at expiry. Nobody needs an account.
The difference is size. A drop holds 25 MB: enough for contracts, scans, keys and config files, not for video, disk images or large archives. And unlike Send, a drop has no password option. The link is the key, so send it through a channel you trust, or put a password on a secure note instead.
Try it on ProtectedShare
Free, with no account. Each tool encrypts in your browser before anything is uploaded. The security model lists exactly what the server stores.
- File dropFiles up to 25 MB, encrypted in your browser and deleted after 1 to 100 downloads.
- Secure NotesA note encrypted in your browser. Burns after one read by default; add a password to send separately.
- EnvShare.env files, API keys and passwords, deleted after 1 to 100 reads or at expiry.
- Secret requestSend someone a link. What they type back is encrypted to a key only your browser holds.
Questions
Is Firefox Send still available?
No. Mozilla took Firefox Send offline in the summer of 2020 and announced on September 17, 2020 that it would not return, citing people using it to ship malware and run spear phishing attacks. Its source code is archived on GitHub.
What was Firefox Send's file size limit?
1 GB without an account, and 2.5 GB with a free Firefox Account, according to Mozilla's launch announcement. Mozilla's FAQ added that very large files could strain your computer, since encryption ran in the browser.
What can I use instead of Firefox Send?
For files up to 25 MB, ProtectedShare's file drop works the way Send did: encrypted in your browser, the key in the link, a download limit and an expiry. For bigger files, a community fork of Send can be self-hosted, Bitwarden Send takes up to 500 MB on paid plans, and WeTransfer handles multi-gigabyte transfers with encryption in transit and at rest.
Was Firefox Send end-to-end encrypted?
Yes. Mozilla described Send as end-to-end encrypted, and its documentation explains that files were encrypted in the browser with AES-GCM through the Web Crypto API, with the key appended to the link as a fragment. ProtectedShare's file drop encrypts with AES-256-GCM in the browser the same way.
Can I self-host Firefox Send?
Mozilla's code is available under the Mozilla Public License 2.0, but the repository is archived and Mozilla asks that copies drop its branding. A community fork, timvisee/send, is maintained for self-hosting. ProtectedShare is MIT licensed and can be self-hosted on Cloudflare Workers.